Countdown to the Republican Primary Debate: Who Will Make the Cut

The Republican Party’s first primary debate in August saw eight candidates take the stage, but the upcoming debate later this month may have fewer contenders. With less than two weeks remaining until the second debate of the Republican presidential primaries, candidates are racing against time to meet the stringent qualification criteria set by the Republican National Committee (RNC). This article explores the challenges candidates face, their chances of qualifying, and the potential implications of a smaller candidate field.

The Republican National Committee’s Qualification Criteria:

To host the debate on September 27, each candidate must meet the following criteria:
1. Secure at least 3 percent support in two qualified national polls.
2. Attain at least 3 percent support in one national poll and the same figure in two different early voting state polls conducted since August 1.
3. Provide evidence of attracting a minimum of 50,000 unique donors to their campaign.
4. Pledge to support the party’s eventual nominee in the 2024 presidential election.

The Potential for Fewer Candidates:

As it stands, there is a likelihood that not all eight candidates who participated in the initial debate will qualify for the upcoming one. Six of the candidates appear to have met the criteria, having also signed the RNC pledge for the first debate. However, North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum and former Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchinson may struggle to meet the higher thresholds set for September. Furthermore, former President Donald Trump, who easily qualified for the first debate but skipped it, seems determined to avoid the second debate as well.

Prominent Candidates in the Race:

Based on an analysis conducted on September 13, 2023, at least six candidates are well-positioned to participate in the second Republican debate. These candidates meet Mystockprediction’s “top” candidate criteria, as indicated in the table below:

CandidatePoll RatingsDonorsSigned Commitment for the First Debate
Ron DeSantis
Vivek Ramaswamy
Nikki Haley
Mike Pence
Chris Christie
Tim Scott
Donald Trump
David Burgum
Asa Hutchinson
Will Hurd

Candidates’ qualification is based on meeting both the polling and donor thresholds set by the RNC, along with signing the pledge to support the eventual Republican presidential candidate.

Analysis of Prominent Candidates:

Mystockprediction’s analysis reveals that Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis and tech entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy have consistently earned at least 3 percent support in qualifying polls, as has former President Donald Trump. Additionally, former U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley, former Vice President Mike Pence, former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie, and South Carolina Sen. Tim Scott have achieved this threshold in the majority of polls. These candidates have also successfully attracted the required 50,000 donors to their campaigns.

Challenges Faced by Other Candidates:

For candidates who have not yet qualified, the increase in the polling threshold from 1 percent to 3 percent poses a significant hurdle. While some, like David Burgum, have reached the donor threshold, their polling numbers remain below the 3 percent mark. Burgum, for instance, only reached 3 percent in one state survey, which could be disputed by his campaign. The RNC’s strict rules on poll inclusion make it challenging for candidates to round off poll results reported with decimals.

Former President Trump’s Role:

The presence, or absence, of former President Trump has a significant impact on the debate process. Despite consistently polling above 50 percent, Trump remains unpredictable. After missing the first debate, he seems inclined to skip the second one as well.

Implications of Trump’s Absence:

Without Trump’s presence, the second debate may become a showdown between the primary alternative candidates. However, none of them appear to pose a substantial challenge to Trump’s candidacy. Nevertheless, it remains crucial for candidates to qualify for the debate, as failure to do so could signal to donors that their campaigns lack viability. Additionally, the absence of Trump provides an opportunity for other Republican contenders to gain exposure and potentially alter the course of their campaigns.


As the countdown to the Republican primary debate continues, candidates are striving to meet the stringent RNC qualification criteria. With the possibility of a reduced candidate field, the dynamics of the race are evolving. While former President Trump’s intentions remain uncertain, the competition among candidates remains fierce. The outcome of the debate could potentially reshape the trajectory of the 2024 Republican presidential campaign.

#Republican #debate #smaller #Trump

Leave a Comment