Comprehensive Examination of the Ron DeSantis Era and Its Implications

by

The political landscape of Florida has undergone significant transformations in recent years, with Governor Ron DeSantis emerging as a prominent figure in the state’s political narrative. His decisive re-election in 2022 has led to claims of a fundamental shift from a swing state to a reliably Republican stronghold. However, the extent of DeSantis’ influence on this transformation remains a subject of debate. In this comprehensive analysis, we delve deeper into the factors driving Florida’s political evolution, evaluate Governor DeSantis’ role, and consider the implications for the state’s future.

Florida’s Pre-Existing Population Growth
Florida’s population had been on an upward trajectory even before the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. While it’s undeniable that the pandemic had a significant impact on the state, leading to an influx of new residents, it’s crucial to recognize that this trend was already in motion. According to American Community Survey Estimates, a substantial 674,740 people relocated to Florida from other states or the District of Columbia in 2021, marking the most substantial domestic immigration to any state. However, when viewed in the context of Florida’s historical population growth, this surge does not appear extraordinary.

Motivations Behind Migration
To understand the motivations behind the migration to Florida, we must consider the reasons people choose to relocate. While no scientific survey has comprehensively addressed this question, an open call by the Tampa Bay Times in 2022 shed light on some common motivations. Responses highlighted factors such as lower taxes, affordable housing prices, and favorable weather as primary drivers of relocation. These motivations align with broader research that suggests individuals typically move for financial reasons rather than purely political ones. While lower taxes may have political implications, it is also an economic incentive deeply rooted in Florida’s history (personal income taxes have been banned in the state since 1968).

DeSantis’ Contribution to Building the Republican Party
Governor DeSantis has made substantial investments in expanding the reach of the state’s Republican Party. Under his leadership, the party has experienced significant growth in registered voters. His efforts have led to a net gain of over 40,000 Republican voters in 2019, marking the most substantial gain in the year preceding a presidential election in decades. DeSantis continued to bolster the party’s numbers in 2020, adding nearly half a million net voters. In 2021, he contributed $2 million to registration drives, ultimately leading to registered Republicans outnumbering Democrats. By 2022, the Republican Party had achieved a remarkable feat, adding 188,323 Republicans to its ranks during a midterm year—a record not seen in two decades.

Examining Historical Registration Trends
While DeSantis’ contribution to the Republican Party’s growth is undeniable, it’s essential to place it within the context of historical registration trends. The chart below illustrates that the Republican Party had been narrowing the registration gap with Democrats for several years before DeSantis assumed office in 2019. This accelerated growth in Republican registrations can be partially attributed to former President Donald Trump’s campaigns in 2016 and 2020.

Democratic Party’s Decline in Registrations
Florida’s political landscape also witnessed a decline in Democratic Party registrations, which played a significant role in the Republican Party’s ascendancy. Despite population growth, the Florida Democratic Party struggled to invest in the registration efforts required to counter natural attrition. Had the party maintained its registration numbers from the end of 2020, registered Democrats would still outnumber Republicans statewide, despite DeSantis’ best efforts.

Gains Among Hispanic Voters: A Complex Narrative
Another noteworthy aspect of Florida’s political evolution is the significant inroads made by Republicans among Hispanic voters. This demographic shift has had a profound impact on the state’s political landscape. However, attributing this shift solely to DeSantis oversimplifies the complex narrative.

Hispanic Voter Trends
The rightward shift among Hispanic voters in Florida began before the 2022 campaign. In the 2020 presidential election, President Biden secured just 50 percent of the Hispanic vote in Florida, according to Catalist, a data firm specializing in voter data analysis. This marked a substantial decline from the 66 percent of the Hispanic vote that former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton received in the 2016 presidential race.

Trump’s Role in Attracting Hispanic Voters
Former President Donald Trump’s appeal to Hispanic voters played a pivotal role in the Republican Party’s increasing support within this demographic. Trump’s advocacy for economic reopening during the pandemic resonated with Hispanic voters, and targeted outreach to Florida’s diverse Hispanic communities further solidified this support. The rightward shift of Latinos is not exclusive to Florida but is a national phenomenon. Nationally, Hispanic support for Democrats decreased from 71 percent in 2016 to 62 percent in both 2020 and 2022.

Unique Hispanic Population in Florida
It’s essential to acknowledge that Florida’s Hispanic population differs from the national norm. While the majority of Latinos in the United States are of Mexican-American descent, Florida’s Hispanic community primarily consists of individuals of Cuban, Puerto Rican, South American, and other backgrounds. These diverse backgrounds may lead to different political priorities among Florida’s Hispanic voters.

Turnout Disparities Among Hispanic Voters
An additional factor that influenced the Republican Party’s success among Hispanic voters in 2022 was disparities in voter turnout. According to Florida Democratic data analyst Matthew Isbell, there were 959,980 registered Hispanic Democrats in Florida at the time of the 2022 election, compared to 728,027 registered Hispanic Republicans. However, voter turnout among Hispanic Democrats was notably lower, with only about a third casting their votes, compared to over half of Hispanic Republicans. This turnout discrepancy played a pivotal role in the Republican Party’s success among Hispanic voters in 2022.

2022 Turnout Disparities: A Broader Issue
A more comprehensive analysis of the 2022 turnout data reveals a more significant issue for DeSantis’ narrative. Much of his success, across demographics, can be attributed to disparities in voter turnout. Overall, 63.4 percent of registered Republicans voted in 2022, whereas only 48.6 percent of registered Democrats did the same. This 14.8-point turnout gap significantly deviated from the turnout trends observed in the 2016, 2018, and 2020 elections in

Florida.

The Uncertain Future of Florida’s Political Landscape
Governor DeSantis has asserted that Florida’s future remains firmly Republican. However, this assertion may not be entirely accurate when viewed through the lens of a single election. The 2022 election featured a unique set of circumstances, notably a substantial partisan turnout gap. Making sweeping predictions based on a single election may be imprudent, as Florida’s political landscape remains dynamic, shaped by a multitude of factors beyond any single candidate or campaign.

Conclusion
Florida’s political transformation and Governor Ron DeSantis’ role in it are multifaceted narratives influenced by numerous factors. While DeSantis has undoubtedly played a part in expanding the Republican Party’s reach and mobilizing voters, ascribing Florida’s shift solely to him oversimplifies the story. The state’s demographic changes, historical trends, and unique population composition all contribute to its evolving political landscape. As we move forward, it’s imperative to acknowledge the nuanced nature of Florida politics and approach any analysis with a holistic perspective.

Read more

Leave a Comment